Our team of experienced risk management and benefits consulting professionals is the biggest reason for our success. We’re constantly looking to get better, smarter, and more efficient at what we do—which is why we’ve continued to grow and thrive over the last 50 years. We love what we do, and we demonstrate that every single day through our commitment to our clients and partners.
Michael M Bill is the chairman of the Board of Directors at MJ Insurance, a company he co-founded in 1964. MJ Insurance is the result of a shared vision to create an independent insurance agency based on sound financial principles and strong customer service which has since grown into one of the top 100 independent insurance agencies in the nation as well as a “Best Place to Work” in Indiana for the past 7 years.
His leadership and determination have enabled MJ Insurance to outpace its peers, becoming the largest locally-owned, privately held, independent agency in Indiana. With over 50 years in business, Michael’s strategic positioning and strong financial management has allowed MJ to grow into a true market leader.DOWNLOAD BIO
Michael H Bill joined the MJ Insurance team in 1992 as a producer in the Property & Casualty and Surety departments. He became president in 2001 where he oversaw the company’s insurance operations and was named chief executive officer in the fall of 2006. Being “purpose-driven,” Michael offers his unique visions, broad experience and wealth of knowledge to all he comes into contact with while focusing on the positive impact he may have upon key constituents – MJ associates and their families, clients, partners, and our local communities.
Michael aligns his philosophy with the principles the company was founded upon. Michael believes you must strive to earn and maintain trust, by continually acting in our clients’ best interest. Each and every transaction conducted by our organization is done in a professional manner, placing our integrity above all else. Simply put, our goal is to do what we say that we are going to do and do it with honesty and sincerity.DOWNLOAD BIO
Jon Loftin joined MJ Insurance in 2004 as chief operating officer and assumed the role of president in 2006. He is responsible for setting the vision and strategic direction of the firm and oversight of the day-to-day execution while ensuring profitable growth. Throughout his successful tenure, Jon has developed and implemented strategic business plans leading to substantial revenue and profit growth for the company. He continually concentrates on shaping a business environment where growth and development flourish.
Jon brings MJ’s core values to life at all levels of the organization by championing significant process and performance improvements, through driving change, accountability and excellence. Jon considers MJ’s greatest asset to be their people. He believes in developing people, building managers and unleashing innovation. Jon ensures that all team members understand MJ’s purpose and passions, and exactly how their role influences the success of the company.DOWNLOAD BIO
Brian Friend brings more than 22 years of financial experience to the MJ team. As MJ’s chief financial officer, Brian brings invaluable insight of an industry veteran to help our company become one of today’s leading insurance agencies. Brian is responsible for strategic planning as well as budget formulation, acquisition structuring, shareholder planning and is focused on the financial health and success of MJ.
Brian is also a member of MJ’s Value Creation Team which is responsible for providing the strategic direction for MJ in alignment with our purpose. Prior to joining MJ, Brian worked for the accounting firm of BKD (formerly Olive, LLP) where he primarily served construction, agri-business and insurance agency industries. Brian brings with him a firm understanding of finance and what it takes for a business to succeed.DOWNLOAD BIO
Donna Bender brings nearly 40 years of experience with Employee Benefits and Property & Casualty insurance to MJ, where she serves as executive vice president of operations. Donna oversees the performance and instruction for all of the MJ service teams, which include: IT, Property & Casualty, Commercial Claims, Employee Benefits, Surety/Bonds, Personal Lines, and the Administrative departments. Along with serving as executive vice president of operations, Donna sits on MJ’s Value Creation Team – a team charged with providing the strategic direction for MJ in alignment with our purpose.
Donna’s knowledge and experience in the insurance industry has been fundamental to MJ’s efforts to train and develop staff. Her role in the company and ability to make a positive impact on MJ’s growth and prosperity has allowed MJ to set itself apart from other agencies.DOWNLOAD BIO
J. Colin MacNab joined the MJ Insurance team in 1993 and brings with him over twenty years of experience. As executive vice president of our Property & Casualty department, Colin oversees activities in our large commercial department as well as serving as risk management consultant to our Japanese-owned Business, Manufacturing, Construction and Service industries. Along with functioning as EVP and risk management consultant, Colin sits on MJ’s Value Creation Team – a team charged with providing the strategic direction for MJ in alignment with our purpose.
Colin maintains a proactive approach when working one-on-one with his clients. He strives to continually focus on building long-lasting relationships by keeping open lines of communication as well as truly learning about his clients needs as a business. With decades of experience, his expertise lies in across many industries and operations. His unique experience with alternative risk transfer, including captive formulation, enables him to design risk management solutions that are customized to every client.DOWNLOAD BIO
Andy Vetor began his insurance career in 2002 as employee benefits consultant at MJ Insurance and quickly grew to become one of the agency’s top performers. His track record for growth and leadership has continued to develop throughout his career, as he became one of the youngest principals in company history. Andy was named executive vice president of our Employee Benefits department in 2013 and was appointed to the Value Creation Team – a team charged with providing the strategic direction for the firm – that same year.
Andy’s expertise lies in consulting group clients on cost-saving benefit solutions. He works with his clients to understand their unique business objectives and designs innovative strategies that align with the company’s corporate goals. Andy has a broad base of specialties including employee relations and communications, benefits technology, plan design analysis and consumer driven health plans, along with extensive experience in the development and implementation of employer sponsored onsite clinics and wellness programs. At MJ Insurance, Andy and his team work to provide value and unparalleled service to all of their clients, a longstanding value that continues today.DOWNLOAD BIO
Cindy H. Stellhorn joined the MJ Insurance team in 1998 and currently functions as the executive vice president of MJ’s Sorority division. She brings nearly four decades of insurance experience to MJ with adept knowledge in the field of sororities and fraternal organizations and risk management. Past experience includes her role as chief operating officer and sorority department manager at Conseco.
Cindy is a firm believer in giving back to the community and participates in several philanthropic organizations. She has served on the board for the Boys & Girls Club of Noblesville as well as a past President for the Independent Insurance Agents of Central Indiana.DOWNLOAD BIO