• Private Exchange
  • Tailored solutions
  • Celebrating 50 years
  • Consultative approach. Expert advice.
  • RM resource

Risk Management. Commercial Insurance. Employee Benefits. HR Consulting.

Since 1964, MJ Insurance has grown to become one of the top 100 ranked insurance agencies in the United States. We've accomplished this by counseling our clients on ways to mitigate risk and providing comprehensive, tailored solutions that lessen their exposure to loss, all with one focus of helping them achieve their business and personal goals.

We value relationships because without them we can't do what we do. In fact, it's the trust, loyalty and integrity - the bonds we build with our clients, as well as within our organization and industry - that define us as a company.

Why MJ?

Responsive, innovative and committed, we use our strengths to your advantage. We take the time to understand the unique challenges and finer nuances of our clients' businesses. Additionally, we offer specialized knowledge, industry expertise, competitive pricing, unparalleled service and access to the best carriers in the industry.

Partnering & Consulting

As the marketplace changes so must businesses. Which is why you need solutions, not just products. Solutions allow for contingencies. Products don't. Which is why we monitor, assess, measure, guide and provide insight - all with the goal of helping your business mitigate risk, lessen exposure to loss and manage human resource needs. Just as many of our clients consider us an extension of their business, we strive to be more than your broker - we work with you as a partner.

Proactive & Passionate

We don't rest until we've found the right solution for your business. Always 100% committed and passionate, our team will be your strongest advocate for your risk management, insurance, employee benefit and human resource matters.


Whether it's an advanced technology tool or a groundbreaking risk management solution, we consistently provide creative methods of transferring risks, communicating information to our clients and developing service enhancements to bring new approaches to our business partnerships.

Recent Blog Posts

Change Needed to Change Attendance

April 22, 2015

We already discussed the power of combining a reward for consistent attendance with a deterrent to minimize missed days among employees.  But have you considered the company's role in any trends?  Read More

Nothing to Sneeze At: Absenteeism Costs Employers Plenty

April 08, 2015

Unless you're a drug manufacturer or doctor's office, why should you care about allergy season? Because allergies claim over 3 million work days per year...  Read More

Giving Back

March 25, 2015

As many other companies do, MJ participates in a multitude of programs to "give back" to our communities and we do so in order to help these deserving organizations fulfill their missions and improve the lives of those that they serve.  Read More

The Million Dollar Question - Are you Ready? Protect yourself against large liability claims

March 11, 2015

What a difference three little zeroes can make.  A million, a billion, a trillion. While a million dollars is hardly a measly little amount, it's easy to reach when considering claims for a catastrophic liability loss.  Read More

Bringing It Home

February 11, 2015

Group of associates from MJ travel to Ensenada, Mexico and assist with a home build for a local family through Youth with a Mission.  Read More

Workday Check Ups: Onsite clinics make it easy to say ahh

January 14, 2015

Is there a doctor in the house? In workplaces nationwide, it's becoming more likely that the answer is "Yes."  Read More

Happy Holidays from MJ Insurance

December 24, 2014

As we enter into the Holiday Season and wind down another year, I can't help but sit back and reflect on all of the things that occurred over the past year at MJ Insurance  Read More

Please join us in support of Dayspring Center Family Homeless Shelter

December 12, 2014

Help us support the efforts of Dayspring to bring much needed services to the homeless families of Indianapolis.  Read More

Give a little THANKS...it's good for your health

December 10, 2014

When is the last time someone went out of their way to tell you "Thank You?"  I don't mean a "Thank You" for holding the door for them or something casual like that.  Rather, a written note or a phone call just to say "Thank You?"  Read More

VOTE for our video with Dayspring Center for this year's Super Service Challenge

December 03, 2014

A team of MJ associates had the pleasure of serving at Dayspring Center for this year's Super Service Challenge.  Read More


April 9, 2015
Agency department honored with 2014 Model Book Award by Central Insurance Companies More

March 23, 2015
Three employees added to MJ's Indianapolis location More

February 19, 2015
Agency named to prestigious ranking by Indiana Chamber of Commerce More

January 19, 2015
MJ Insurance Executive Vice President Cindy Stellhorn speaks on insurance costs for sororities More

November 11, 2014
Business Insurance Broker Beat video featuring MJ Insurance President & COO Jon Loftin More

November 4, 2014
Employee Benefits Consultant, Kevin Sliwa featured on Money Sense - An Ounce of Prevention - Health Insurance More

September 22, 2014
Agency recognized for outstanding workplace culture and best practices More

Contact Us

Have a question? Need an answer? Get in touch


Our associates play an integral role in our success as a business. We are always in the market for talented professionals to join the MJ team. Get in touch